CW: Discussion of suicide.
Since 2020, I’ve been teaching an undergrad class I call Trans Social Movements, which studies the past, present, and future of transgender organizing. I’m actually updating the syllabus now, including going over the readings to remember what worked, what didn’t, and what’s worth adding (in this case, Jules Gill-Peterson’s excellent A Short History of Trans Misogyny). By now, tho0ugh, I have a pretty good core of historical readings that cover major moments. Most of them do a great job getting across the historical context, but there’s one that I never know how a given class will react to when I screen it in-class: this 1987 episode of The Phil Donahue Show on crossdressing. Unlike documentaries like Queens at Heart (1967) or Behind Every Good Man (1967), something about this episode will baffle them. Usually one of the first conversations is about the specifics of the talk show format, from the role of the host to the panel framing to the semi-adversarial audience. Sometimes they question why you’d go on one of these shows at all, if people were just going to (in their view) talk down to you on television. Because unlike the documentaries, why we’re watching the guests have their lives questioned on national television by total strangers isn’t immediately clear.the purpose of watching this can be less clear. (Usually this provides an opportunity to remind them of what the pre-Internet media landscape looked like. If I had the time, we’d read a chapter from Joshua Gamson’s great Freaks Talk Back.)
But there’s one thing every class I’ve screened it in has struggled with, though we read extensively about them in prior weeks: being confronted with real heterosexual crossdressers. Even with all that context, they’ll still try and fit them into modern frameworks. “So, wait…they’re not trans women?” No, though some of their personal identities might have shifted later in life – we don’t know for some of them. “But they use female names and pronouns?” Yes, sometimes. “But not all the time?” Nope, usually just when en femme. “So wait, are they drag queens?” Also no! “So what are they then?” Heterosexual crossdressers! Even after the whole conversation, some students will still talk about them using contemporary frameworks and language. (This isn’t entirely their fault, though: The documentary Casa Susanna (2023), which they also watch and discuss, makes the same mistake. As with our Donahue screening, I have to talk through the differences in class.)
The persistence of this struggle, to me, signifies just how far the heterosexual crossdresser has receded from public and community view since the height of their power within the community during the 1980s. The 1980s are an interesting time in American transgender history. If the 1970s were a moment of visibility, the 1980s were notable for how invisible trans folks were in wider American public life. In part, this invisibility wasn’t accidental. The closure of the clinic system, anti-trans radical feminism, and the rise of the Moral Majority all contributed to a largely inhospitable public environment for gender nonconformity, and funding from organizations like Erickson Education Foundation had dried up.
Given these challenges, organizing was increasingly focused on developing internal community networks. Small local groups as well as regional alliances like MAGGIE (the Mid-America (or Midwest Area) Gender Group Information Exchange), would blossom across the US, driven by an extensive print newsletter network. Though groups varied in who was allowed memberships, heterosexual crossdressers were the most visible and active members of these groups. How they approached crossdressing varied–to paraphrase what one of the Donahue guests says at one point, ask ten crossdressers how and why people crossdress and you’ll get ten different answers–but there were clearly demographic similarities and cultural norms.
As a culture, heterosexual crossdressing prioritized white, middle class perspectives and desires. “Full” participation didn’t always come cheap, including membership fees, magazine subscriptions, acquiring a whole second wardrobe and associated items, and the funds and leisure time to attend weekend conferences and events. It also placed an overwhelming focus on privacy and discretion. Most authors went by first name only and made only vague references to other parts of their lives–references that other group members could decipher but would be lost on the unfamiliar reader. And authors exhorted readers to use a post office box, lest their neighbors find out about their “activities.” A 1990 issue of Femme Mirror, the magazine of major crossdressing organization Tri-Ess, includes the cautionary tale of a married Florida crossdresser, entitled “So You Think You Don’t Need a Post Office Box,” who forgot to update their mailing address with their local group when they sold their house. The new owner sent the group newsletter to the member’s new house in an envelope addressed to their wife, outing them.
For even as they longed to be seen and build community with like-minded individuals, the focus on privacy remained paramount throughout the 1980s into the mid-1990s. As Jules Gill-Peterson notes of the Transvestia subscribers and Casa Susanna’s visitors thirty years earlier, this focus on maintaining privacy “ratifie[s] a bourgeois distinction between public and private.” In other words, participation in formal “community” was limited to those who could afford it, economically and socially. It would be these groups who developed and supported the organizational infrastructure from which the “transgender movement” could emerge beginning in the mid-1990s. They couldn’t have done it, however, if they hadn’t been able to hold onto their social and economic privilege as (to the wider world) middle-class men. And the “transgender” movement that would succeed these crossdressers would work to create a world that would render their cultural norms (or I would argue, their very mode of approaching gender nonconformity) obsolete.
All of this, I explain to students, is what made these talk show appearances so notable–members of the gender community had very few opportunities to reach a mass audience, so they took advantage of what they could get. Because even though they could hold huge personal risk, they also knew these appearances could be life-saving.
Because that’s the other thing: even as the language has changed, suicide has always been a specter hovering over trans life. There are multiple letters and columns to the Femme Mirror about the life-saving benefits of membership. Sometimes, it’s just the traces left behind, like this anonymous poem from Spring 1993, whose author committed suicide a week after writing it. Similar to Morgan M. Page, I don’t mention these cases to engage in shroud-waving, but I see “the absences of the disappeared” in these stories. Those who didn’t run across a group’s hotline number in the classifieds of their local alternative weekly paper on the two weeks the group could afford to run an ad or find the doctored entry in the library card catalog that directed information seekers to their local group before a librarian replaced it. Who were never able to find community. Even with all their racial and/or class privilege, it couldn’t give them the community needed. That they had to find in a world that didn’t want them to exist.
All of this secrecy and fear was, of course, massively alleviated by the Internet (there may be a whole book on that…). The Internet made it possible for trans youth to emerge as a recognizable demographic group. Yet there are forces that would like nothing more than to revert us to the 1980s, as seen in the Kids Online Safety Act (KOSA) and platforms like Instagram’s anticipatory compliance. To a moment when one could only learn about transness through a secret P.O. Box or on a hotline. Like Page, I struggle with hope as a discipline. But I’m going to do my best to hold on to it, until bills like KOSA seem as foreign to my students as an old, scratchy digitized VHS taping of Donahue.
Leave a Reply